Love Island enthusiasts are speculating about the potential winners of the ITV2 series, but a dilemma has arisen.

In the latest episode aired on Sunday night (February 18), the couples – Tom Clare and Molly Smith, Callum Jones and Jess Gale, Toby Aromolaran and Georgia Steel, Anton Danyluk and Georgia Harrison, and Josh Ritchie and Sophie Piper – were informed they had reached the Love Island All Stars final.

This unexpected format change, with five couples instead of the usual four reaching the finale, prompted fans to share their predictions on which duo might emerge victorious.

Many fans are leaning towards Callum and Jess as potential winners, despite expressing doubts about their connection. On social media, they highlighted that the pair could clinch the crown despite “barely speaking” to each other in the villa.

“Not Callum and Jess winning when they barely speak to each other,” remarked one viewer. Another questioned, “Am I missing something why are people voting Callum and Jess when they have no chemistry? I get people love Callum but it’s the COUPLE that wins?”

A third commenter concurred, noting, “Every time Callum spoke about his couple he said he is happy but never mentioned how they would last outside, he doesn’t like Jess.” Others expressed frustration, with one stating, “Why am I seeing 50% votes for Jess and Callum and 50% votes for Sophie and Josh? Jess and Callum have zero chemistry. Yes Callum is lovely but they make a boring couple.”

These discussions come after Adam Maxted and Arabella Chi narrowly missed out on the final following a brutal elimination.

In the recent episode, the All Stars cast returned to the villa to vote out one couple. Each Islander was tasked with voting for the couple they wanted to eliminate and stating their reason. It resulted in a tie between Anton and Georgia H and Adam and Arabella, with Joe Garratt, Arabella’s former flame, casting the deciding vote. Joe justified his decision by stating that Adam and Arabella weren’t as “strong as the rest”.

Arabella, visibly emotional, bid farewell to her fellow Islanders, expressing her belief in an interview with host Maya Jama that the Islanders made the wrong decision and should have voted out Anton and Georgia H, emphasising the strength of her connection with Adam.