Christina Ricci and Cher have not repaired the relationship they formed while playing mother and daughter in Mermaids. Ricci says the silence began after she failed to return an apologetic voicemail when she was 19, a decision that apparently has impressive staying power.

Speaking to Andy Cohen on the November 17 episode of Watch What Happens Live, the 46-year-old actor said Cher remains upset with her nearly three decades later.

“Unfortunately, she’s still mad at me,” Ricci said. “She holds a grudge.”

What caused the rift between the former costars?

Ricci traced the problem to a magazine feature published when she was 19. She initially remembered it as a Rolling Stone piece, although she said it may have appeared in Première. The publication interviewed Cher, and Ricci felt the resulting comments about her were less than flattering.

Cher, born Cheryl Sarkisian, later called to explain that the interview had not represented her fairly.

“She left me a voicemail about how journalists are always trying to get the worst things,” Ricci recalled. Cher said she was sorry, but the teenager did not call back.

That unanswered message seems to have become the central issue. Ricci said she has tried to reconnect since then, only to receive “radio silence.” Cher’s representative had not responded to a request for comment, so the account currently comes from Ricci alone.

The dispute is strikingly small for one that has lasted this long. There was no public argument, dramatic confrontation or elaborate betrayal. There was simply an interview, an apology and one voicemail left unanswered. Apparently, telecommunications etiquette can have a very long afterlife.

Why Ricci says she understands Cher’s reaction

Ricci made clear that she does not resent Cher. If anything, she now views the incident from the singer’s perspective and understands why the ignored apology may have felt insulting.

“I adore her. She’s the best,” Ricci said. She imagined Cher believing she had been misquoted, reaching out to reassure a younger colleague and then receiving no response.

“And then the gall of that young person to not return the call and be like, ‘Oh, my God, Cher, it’s okay. I love you so much,’” Ricci said. “Like, I would be so pissed. I get it.”

The actor ended her account with a direct message for the 80-year-old Grammy winner: “Love you, Cher. I love you so much.”

Whether that declaration works better than the previous attempts remains unclear. Cher has not publicly addressed Ricci’s latest comments, and Ricci offered no indication that contact has resumed.

Their bond began on the set of Mermaids

Cher and Ricci met while making the 1990 coming-of-age film Mermaids. Cher played Rachel Flax, while Ricci portrayed her daughter Kate Flax. Winona Ryder played Rachel’s older daughter, Charlotte.

Their connection continued beyond the production. In the 2024 documentary Child Star, Ricci told Demi Lovato that Cher had protected and guided her while she was still learning how film sets worked.

“Cher took me under her wing,” Ricci said. She explained that young actors could easily misunderstand behind-the-scenes tensions, including power struggles and other production problems. Without experience, a child performer might assume those difficulties were somehow their fault.

According to Ricci, Cher made sure she did not internalize that uncertainty. “She never wanted me to feel insecure,” she said.

That history helps explain why Ricci still speaks warmly about her former costar despite the prolonged silence. The relationship may be nonexistent now, but Ricci’s affection clearly is not. One unreturned call changed the friendship, though it did not erase what Cher meant to her when she was young.